Housing and Communism
Monday, August 30th, 2010I’ve been reading a lot about the housing crisis in China. (also here and here, and a billion other places).
And since I majored in Russian, I have vivid memories from my Soviet history courses of memoirs and other primary sources that described the acute housing crisis that plagued the Soviet government for pretty much the entirety of its existence (not that the preceding or following system did a much better job of it). Collective flats, with five families to an apartment, seemed to be the best they could do - and it wasn’t very much fun for anyone, and it still required a massive and agonizing government bureaucracy to keep people in place.
So I’m wondering: does anyone know of any examples of a socialist system that was able to deal with this problem?
I’m not saying this to be critical of communist or socialist economic systems. I ask this as someone who feels strongly that alternatives to and/or radical restructuring of capitalism is necessary. I just find it interesting that this fundamental problem that most radicals in the West (including myself) attribute to the free market, did not go away in the absence of the free market.
And while I know the principles are similar, I am NOT talking about land reform. I know there’s lots of examples of a socialist government taking land away from rich/foreign/noble landlords and redistributing it to the agrarian working class. That seems to work out a lot better.
I’m talking about housing in an urban setting. The same thing we talk about here in New York when we talk about homelessness and the high cost of housing and the staggering, bewildering, depressing power of the real estate lobby in controlling the political process. The same thing we think would be fine, just as soon as we can take it out of the clutches of the free market…
And for my Marxist/economics friends out there, are there any great analyses of WHY some of the most iconic socialist governments failed to tackle this fundamental indicator of inequality and injustice?











