“Great writing should challenge us and make us uncomfortable and push our boundaries. By such standards, the writing in BASS is not necessarily the best.”
Thursday, December 9th, 2010Roxane Gay is pissing off a lot of people with a little bit of truth.
She published a critique of racial representation in the latest edition of “Best American Short Stories.” This got tons of comments, many of them managing to be defensive and condescending all at once (”Okay maybe you mentioned Toni Morrisson [sic], but we all went to college so that doesn’t count.”).
I haven’t read BASS 2010, so I can’t say how spot-on she is… but I can say that the REASON I haven’t read it is because it’s almost always boring as hell, and that’s due to the monotony of the stories being told… i.e. the lack of diversity not just in racial terms, but also in terms of the stories being told and the class background of the characters. I hope I won’t do Roxane’s thesis an injustice by summing it up with a direct quote that obviously leaves out much of the nuance of the full argument: “Almost every story in the anthology was about rich or nearly rich white people to the point where, by the end of reading the book, I was downright offended. I know people will disagree with my thoughts here and that’s fine, but I really think shit is fucked up in literary publishing.”
So what do I have to add to the conversation? Not much. I think Roxane’s a hundred percent right. All I’d say is this: I think the problem is just one part of literary fiction’s slow decline into irrelevancy. On a long train ride recently, I gave my boyfriend an issue of a literary journal that shall remain nameless, and he was horrified at the frivolity and boringness of pretty much everything he read. And he was totally right. I keep buying and subscribing to literary journals, and checking them out of the library, and reading them in bookstores and then putting them back on the shelf, because of that one story in ten that really floors me - but I am not sure I would do so if I didn’t also have a personal commitment to supporting that corner of the literary ecosystem, because I too hope to publish my sh*t there. There’s too many great books out there.
I want literary fiction to be diversified in a lot of ways. I want more racial diversity, but I also want more narrative diversity. I want to feel that sense of risk. I want to be terrified for the characters, and I just can’t give a shit about one more wealthy person trying to find him- or herself. More and more I find myself reading young adult novels and genre fiction because that’s where the hard compelling edgy stories are - with lots of extra verve and energy and robots and clones and cutters.
“…These are books that are written over and over again and at a time when everyone is lamenting the death of publishing, you have to think, however ridiculous and overwrought those laments are, that publishing this one kind of story without accounting for the multitude of other experiences in the world, is not helping publishing stay alive.”















